Primary vs secondary sources: what the difference is and how to tell, in any field
By Mubarak MutesasiraUpdated 11 min read
Short answer:
A primary source is first-hand evidence: a document, object, dataset or study created by people directly involved, at the time. A secondary source analyzes or interprets primary sources from a distance, such as a scholarly book or a review article. A tertiary source, such as an encyclopedia or textbook, summarizes both. Whether a source is primary depends on your research question, not only on the source itself.
This guide shows how the three categories work in history, the sciences, law and business, gives a decision table you can apply to any source, and covers the cases that confuse people most. To judge whether a source is trustworthy, a separate question, see how to evaluate source credibility.
What is a primary source?
A primary source is the raw material of research: evidence created by a participant or witness, or the original report of new data. The Library of Congress describes primary sources as the raw materials of history: original documents and objects created at the time under study [1].
Common primary sources:
- Letters, diaries, speeches, interviews and memoirs
- Government records, laws, treaties and court judgments
- Photographs, recordings, maps and artifacts
- Original research articles reporting new experiments, surveys or analyses
- Datasets, lab notebooks and field notes
- Company filings, annual reports and patents
- Novels, poems, films and artworks, when you study them as works
What is a secondary source?
A secondary source is one step removed: someone who was not part of the event or study explains, interprets or evaluates primary sources. It brings an argument, a summary or a comparison.
Common secondary sources:
- Scholarly books and monographs that interpret evidence
- Review articles, systematic reviews and meta-analyses
- Biographies and histories written later
- Law review articles, treatises and legal commentary
- Literary criticism and film criticism
- Industry analyses and news features written after the event
What is a tertiary source?
A tertiary source condenses primary and secondary sources into reference material for quick lookup. Encyclopedias, textbooks, dictionaries, handbooks, almanacs, bibliographies and databases of abstracts are tertiary.
Use tertiary sources at the start of a project: to learn the vocabulary, find the main debates and get the names of key authors and studies. Then follow their references. Our guide to finding sources for a research paper covers where to go next.
Primary vs secondary vs tertiary at a glance
| Primary | Secondary | Tertiary | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Distance from the event or data | Direct | One step removed | Two or more steps removed |
| What it gives you | Evidence | Interpretation and argument | Summary and background |
| Who made it | A participant, witness or the original researchers | A scholar or writer working from primary sources | A compiler or editor working from many sources |
| Typical use in a paper | The evidence you analyze | The debate you join and the context | Background you usually do not cite |
| Example | Watson and Crick's 1953 paper on the structure of DNA [5] | A review of the history of DNA research | An encyclopedia entry on DNA |
Primary and secondary sources by discipline
Each field draws the line in a slightly different place, so learn your field's usage before you count sources for an assignment. The four tables below use real, checkable sources.
History
History uses the terms most strictly. A primary source comes from the period you study; a secondary source is a later historian's account. Historians read primary sources by asking who made them, when, why and for whom, a habit Sam Wineburg calls "sourcing" [3].
| Type | Example |
|---|---|
| Primary | The Declaration of Independence (1776); letters between John and Abigail Adams; a 1918 newspaper report on influenza |
| Secondary | Bernard Bailyn, The Ideological Origins of the American Revolution (Harvard University Press, 1967) |
| Tertiary | An encyclopedia entry on the American Revolution; a survey textbook |
Sciences and health
In the sciences, the primary literature is the original research article that reports new data. Review articles are secondary literature, and textbooks are tertiary.
| Type | Example |
|---|---|
| Primary | Jinek et al. (2012), the Science paper that showed CRISPR-Cas9 can be programmed to cut chosen DNA sequences [6] |
| Secondary | Doudna and Charpentier (2014), a review in Science of genome engineering with CRISPR-Cas9 [7] |
| Tertiary | A molecular biology textbook chapter on gene editing |
Systematic reviews and meta-analyses are secondary sources in this scheme, even though they are high in the evidence hierarchy for many questions. "Secondary" says how far a source is from the data, not how good it is. Our levels of evidence guide covers quality, and what is a systematic review covers how reviews are built.
Law
Lawyers speak of primary and secondary authority. Primary authority is the law itself; secondary authority explains it and can persuade a court, but does not bind it [4].
| Type | Example |
|---|---|
| Primary | Brown v. Board of Education, 347 U.S. 483 (1954); the US Constitution; a statute; an agency regulation |
| Secondary | A law review article; a legal treatise; the Restatements of the law published by the American Law Institute |
| Tertiary | A legal encyclopedia or a legal dictionary entry |
Restatements are a common trap. Courts cite them often, but they are secondary authority unless a court adopts a section, in which case the court's judgment is the primary authority. For citation format, see the Bluebook generator.
Business and economics
Business research mixes historical, legal and statistical sources. Company documents and official statistics are primary; analyses of them are secondary.
| Type | Example |
|---|---|
| Primary | A company's Form 10-K annual report filed with the US Securities and Exchange Commission, searchable in EDGAR [8]; official statistics; interview transcripts you collected |
| Secondary | An analyst report on the company; a peer-reviewed case study; a business press feature |
| Tertiary | A business encyclopedia or a textbook chapter on corporate strategy |
Researchers in business and social science also distinguish primary data (data you collect yourself through surveys, interviews or experiments) from secondary data (data someone else collected, such as a national census or a published dataset). The terms overlap with primary and secondary sources but are not the same. A census table is secondary data for you, yet it is still a primary source in the document sense. Public datasets such as FRED economic data are a common source of secondary data.
How do you tell if a source is primary or secondary?
Ask what your research question is about, then ask whether the source is direct evidence of that thing or someone's account of it. The same document can change category when the question changes.
Decision table
Work down the table and stop at the first row that matches.
| Question to ask | If yes | Example (illustrative) |
|---|---|---|
| Is the source itself the thing you are studying? | Primary | Studying how newspapers covered vaccines: every article is primary, even opinion pieces |
| Was it created by a participant or eyewitness, at or near the time? | Primary | A nurse's diary from a 1918 influenza ward |
| Does it report data or findings the authors produced themselves? | Primary | A trial report, a survey study, a lab experiment, a company's own filing |
| Is it the text of a law, judgment, treaty or official record? | Primary | A statute, a court opinion, parliamentary minutes |
| Does it analyze, interpret or compare other sources, written later or by someone not involved? | Secondary | A review article, a biography, a law review article, a history book |
| Does it summarize established knowledge for reference, with no new argument? | Tertiary | An encyclopedia, a textbook, a dictionary |
Context changes the answer
Librarians make the same point. The ACRL Framework for Information Literacy asks students to judge a source by how and why it was created and by the context in which it is used, not by its format alone [2].
| Source | Primary when your question is about… | Secondary when your question is about… |
|---|---|---|
| A 1960s biology textbook | How biology was taught in the 1960s | Cell biology (it would be tertiary, and out of date) |
| A historian's 1950 book on the Civil War | How historians wrote about the war in the 1950s | The Civil War itself |
| A review article on remote work | The way researchers framed remote work during 2020 | Whether remote work affects productivity |
| A news interview with a CEO | The CEO's public statements | The company's strategy, if the article adds analysis |
Common mistakes
- Treating "primary" as "better". Primary sources need interpretation and can be biased, partial or wrong. A diary records one person's view. A single study can fail to replicate.
- Calling every journal article primary. Review articles, commentaries and editorials are secondary. Check the article type and the methods section.
- Citing the summary instead of the original. If a review reports a statistic, find and cite the original study, and check it says what the review claims. Our guide on how to find references for a claim shows how.
- Citing tertiary sources as evidence. Encyclopedias and textbooks are for background. Most instructors will not accept them as evidence.
- Using a translation or transcription without saying so. An edited or translated edition of a primary source adds an editor's choices. Cite the edition you used.
Checklist for each source
- What is my research question about?
- Is this source direct evidence of that, or an account of it?
- Who created it, when, and why?
- If it is a journal article, is it original research or a review?
- If it is secondary, have I found and read the primary sources it relies on for the points I use?
- Have I recorded the type in my notes, so I can meet the assignment's requirements?
How to find primary and secondary sources with AI for Research
AI for Research searches over 250 million scholarly works with real records, so you can find original research and reviews and see which is which.
- Find original studies and reviews. In Find Papers, filter by study type to separate original research (trials, cohort studies, surveys) from reviews and meta-analyses, and by year to find work from a period.
- Trace a claim back to its primary source. Start from a review, open its references, and follow the citation trail backward. Our citation snowballing guide explains the method.
- Read the original. Upload a PDF to Chat with PDF and ask "Did the authors collect this data themselves?" Answers cite the page, so you can check.
- Keep track of type. Save papers to your Research Library and tag them primary or secondary. In the free literature review matrix builder, add a column for source type.
Search, filters, citations and the free tools cost nothing. The Free plan includes 45 credits a month for AI features. See pricing. Limits: the scholarly index covers published research, not archives, so for letters, records and other historical primary sources use your library's archives and digital collections such as the Library of Congress [1].
FAQ
What is the difference between primary and secondary sources?
A primary source is first-hand evidence created at the time or by the people involved: a letter, a dataset, a court judgment, an original research article. A secondary source analyzes, interprets or summarizes primary sources from a distance: a history book, a review article, a law review article. The same document can be either, depending on what your research question is about.
Is a journal article a primary or secondary source?
It depends on the article. A research article that reports a new experiment, survey or analysis is a primary source in the sciences and social sciences. A review article, a systematic review or a commentary that discusses other studies is a secondary source. Read the abstract and methods: if the authors collected or analyzed the data themselves, treat it as primary.
What is a tertiary source?
A tertiary source collects and condenses primary and secondary sources into a quick reference: encyclopedias, textbooks, dictionaries, handbooks, fact books and indexes. Tertiary sources are useful for background, definitions and finding key terms and authors. Most instructors do not accept them as evidence in a research paper, so follow them to the secondary and primary sources they rely on.
Is a newspaper article a primary or secondary source?
A news report written at the time of an event is usually a primary source for that event, especially an eyewitness account or interview. A later news feature that analyzes events from a distance is secondary. For a study of how the media covered a topic, any article is primary, because the coverage itself is what you are studying.
Are textbooks primary or secondary sources?
Textbooks are usually tertiary sources, because they summarize a field's established knowledge from many secondary sources. Some people call them secondary. Either way, cite the original research rather than a textbook in a research paper. The exception is research about education or the history of a subject, where an old textbook can be a primary source.
Do I need primary sources for a research paper?
Usually yes. Most research papers need primary sources as evidence and secondary sources to show what others have argued. History and law assignments often require a minimum number of primary sources. In the sciences, the original research articles are your primary literature. Check your assignment brief, and ask your instructor if it does not say.
Next steps
- Check that each source can be trusted: how to evaluate source credibility.
- Turn your sources into an argument: what is a thesis statement.
- Find more sources: how to find sources for a research paper.
- Cite them correctly: how to cite a research paper.
Sources
- Library of Congress. (n.d.). Getting started with primary sources. https://www.loc.gov/programs/teachers/getting-started-with-primary-sources/
- Association of College and Research Libraries. (2016). Framework for information literacy for higher education. American Library Association. https://www.ala.org/acrl/standards/ilframework
- Wineburg, S. (2001). Historical thinking and other unnatural acts: Charting the future of teaching the past. Temple University Press.
- Legal Information Institute. (n.d.). Primary authority. Cornell Law School. https://www.law.cornell.edu/wex/primary_authority
- Watson, J. D., & Crick, F. H. C. (1953). Molecular structure of nucleic acids: A structure for deoxyribose nucleic acid. Nature, 171(4356), 737–738. https://doi.org/10.1038/171737a0
- Jinek, M., Chylinski, K., Fonfara, I., Hauer, M., Doudna, J. A., & Charpentier, E. (2012). A programmable dual-RNA–guided DNA endonuclease in adaptive bacterial immunity. Science, 337(6096), 816–821. https://doi.org/10.1126/science.1225829
- Doudna, J. A., & Charpentier, E. (2014). The new frontier of genome engineering with CRISPR-Cas9. Science, 346(6213), 1258096. https://doi.org/10.1126/science.1258096
- U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission. (n.d.). EDGAR full text search. https://www.sec.gov/edgar/search/